When Sisko Found His Swagger

Earlier this fall I began an epic rewatch of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. From beginning to end. I haven’t seen many of these episodes since they first aired and, in the case of much of the final season, I haven’t seen some at all. I’ve just finished the third season and something has become abundantly clear: Sisko is a much more interesting character now that Avery Brooks is playing him as a black man.
Of course, Brooks is a black man, so it might sound like a strange thing to note, but if you look at the first few seasons, Sisko isn’t just a black guy…he’s the Best Black Guy in The Universe. Brooks is playing the social ideal of a black man. He looks as unimposing as possible, with that Derwin haircut. His speech is so over-enunciated it feels emasculated. It’s as if DS9 was running so far from stereotype they went too far and landed in uninteresting.
But towards the end of the third season — maybe confident that the show wasn’t going anywhere, maybe he just found the groove of the character — Brooks simply relaxed. He stopped punching his syllables, he grew the goatee, he let the music of his voice play a little more. All of this coincided with the introduction of a real love interest for Sisko — and Brooks channeled a bit of the ol’ Barry White, some of Isaac Hayes’ Hot Buttered Soul.
He made Sisko sexy.
And in so doing, made him a man. A man without even that most base set of desires isn’t a man, he’s just a collection of mannerisms…and in Sisko’s case, signifiers of default nobility. Finally, Sisko became an interesting character to watch and Deep Space Nine had a magnetic character to pivot around. And Sisko’s development coincided with the show’s maturation into a series with something to say about cold war and hot peace, while digging into a deep, ongoing mythology.
By the time he shaved his head for the start of the fourth season and went Full Hawk, the transformation of both the character and the show was complete.
